Welcome to Changeboard, the HR jobs & career development site Sign in | Join
Control Panel
image of HRCircles Banner
Hot Seat  My Career  Salary Surveys  Jobs  Forums  Events  C S R  About us  
Back
The truth about the HR department | debate on the HR circuit
One of the trails of commentary I've been following in the HR blogosphere this week is peoples’ and particularly HR practitioners’ reactions to private equity boss, Luke Johnson’s criticism of HR as a 'necessary evil' in the FT.

I commented on it, as did Personnel Today. But the most robust defence of HR was provided by Rick at Flip Chart Fairy Tales who pointed out that at least the article goes beyond repeating the usual gripes. In fact, Johnson thinks HR is so powerful that he compares it to Mossad or the CIA.

Given that, as Rick reminds us, senior HR managers are forever bemoaning their lack of power and influence, perhaps we shouldn’t be too displeased with these comments after all.What do you think? - what do we as HR practitioners need to do to respond to this criticism?  And what about the CIPD?  Should they perhaps be running TV adverts in the UK as SHRM have been doing in the US?

 

Published Monday, 04 February 2008 by Jon Ingham
Filed under:



Comments

 

Editor's Blog said:

In a speech addressed to HR professionals within the financial and professional services sector earlier

February 7, 2008 2:58 PM
To Have Your Say
 

Once you are an HR Circles member you'll be able to interact with the site - join discussion forums, add comments, contribute content, and subscribe to our email updates, digests and newsletters.

Back

Get in touch

We're always looking for experts to get involved and contribute editorial, news, podcasts and video content as well as upcoming events.

Natalie Cooper
Community website editor, Changeboard
T: +44 (0)20 8150 0240
E: natalie@changeboard.com

Bookmarks for This Blog

Subscribe to This Blog

  • RSS
  • Comments RSS
  • Receive Email Updates
    Subscribe
  • Archives of This Blog

     
    © Changeboard 2008 gws